Skip to main content

    Coax vs. conventional hot water tank

    Should you keep your hot water tank or choose a flow-through heater? Compare them in the table, then read when we recommend keeping a tank.

    A conventional tank stores around 200 litres of hot water. COAX heats water as you use it. Each has different requirements for the power supply and installation location.

    Compact wall-mounted tankless water heater compared with a large tank losing heat

    Point by point

    Eighteen differences, from power and space to noise and frost.

    Comparison of a hot water tank and the COAX flow-through heater
    PointHot water tankCOAX
    Type of solutionStorage in a tank, water kept hot around the clockDirect flow-through heating, active only while you draw water
    Electricity useContinuous heat loss (standby loss)No standby loss, uses electricity only in the minutes you draw hot water
    Space requiredTypically 60x60x120 cm, requiring a utility room or storage cupboard9x38x26 cm, can be fitted close to the outlet
    HygieneRisk of bacterial growth in standing waterWater straight from the mains, with no storage in a tank
    CapacityLimited to the tank volume, runs out under heavy useUnlimited hot water, for as long as the tap is open
    MaintenanceNeeds regular anode checks, cleaning and drainingMaintenance-free, with no moving parts
    Service lifeInsurers recommend replacement after 10–15 years, and leaks become more likely with ageStainless steel heating chamber, with no anode
    InstallationNeeds a floor drain and a safety valve, often with long pipe runsSimple installation, small unit, short pipes, no drain needed
    System and pipeworkCentralised, long pipes mean greater heat loss and more waitingDecentralised, heat only where it is needed, almost no waiting
    Frost protection (cabins)Must be drained or kept in a heated room, with a risk of frost damageMinimal frost risk, very small water volume, easy to drain
    Environmental impactHigher energy use and more water wasted while you waitMore environmentally friendly, low electricity consumption and less cold water wasted
    Pressure and flow rateGood pressure, but a limited water supplyStable pressure and a good flow rate, with no pressure drop when several outlets are in use
    Water-saving fixturesLong waiting times make water-saving nozzles impractical, reduce comfort and waste more cold waterHot water arrives quickly, so you can use efficient water-saving fixtures without reducing comfort
    Energy loss in pipesLarge losses over long pipe runs from a central tank to the outletAlmost no losses, short pipes and local heating
    ScalabilityOne large unit that must be sized for peak demandModular: several small units can be installed at different outlets
    NoiseCan produce clicking sounds and expansion noise as water heatsNear-silent operation, no large body of water being heated
    Comfort at the tapWaiting time at the tap, a burst of cold water before the hot arrivesFast response time, fewer temperature swings
    SafetyRisk of leaks or tank failureNo storage tank that can rust through or crack

    When a tank is the right choice

    In these situations we recommend keeping or buying a tank.

    You have 16 A at the cabin

    16 A gives less than 4 kW, which is only enough for a basin. In that case we recommend a small 10 A under-counter tank.

    You have a 230 V IT network and 25 A, with no plans to replace the fuse box

    A 15 to 18 kW shower heater needs a three-phase supply and a 32 to 45 A circuit. If that requires upgrading the supply, keeping the tank until your next renovation is often more economical.

    Your tank is new and working

    A modern, well-insulated tank standing in a room you heat anyway loses little. Wait until it needs replacing, or until the bathroom is due for a refurbishment.

    Many showers running at once on the same circuit

    Several shower heads running at once require multiple heaters connected in parallel. That requires a 400 V supply and a sufficiently high main fuse rating. If you do not have that, a large tank is simpler.

    The saving depends on how much you use

    You avoid the tank's heat loss. Your electricity price and hot water use determine how much that saves in kroner.

    Conventional tank≈ NOK 6,200
    COAX tankless≈ NOK 3,100
    Your savings
    ~50%

    lower annual cost for hot water in this example.